A borrowed idea fighting for the new

For a true writer each book should be a new beginning where he tries again for something that is beyond attainment. He should always try for something that has never been done or that others have tried and failed. Then sometimes, with good luck, he will succeed. -Ernest Hemingway, from his Nobel Prize Speech

Ideas. They are what move the world, shape its consequences, and change the face of an era. The power of an idea was best exemplified in Steve Jobs, who took an existing gadget, and redefined its purpose for a lifestyle. In writing, it all begins with a brand spanking-ly new idea–be it an edge-of-your-seat plot, a loveable (or exasperating) character, or a cover story that will leave your title sold out.

Unfortunately very few popular products of writing seem to exemplify the new beginning Ernest Hemingway emphasizes. Theatres will soon suffer the mind numbing “love story” (aka yet another vampire…wait can we even call him that?!) of Twilight with the first part of Breaking Dawn. Other lesser known books followed suit, as my rounds around bookstores have seen stuff like “How to Date a Vampire.” And seriously, another love story? Don’t even get me started on the rom-coms.

In other mediums, Jose Javier Reyes reveals–or rather, emphasizes–in Rogue’s October issue that Filipino TV lacks variety. Night time shows execute similar plots, and there’s no diversity in genre–just teleseryes, telanovelas, and a dubbed Asian-novela. The local movie world has recently seen more of the same with its yet another cheat-on-the-wife plot, care of the movie No Other Woman (more on that in a future post). The print medium is no exception, with just about every magazine having dropped out beauty products features passing off as articles. Oh, and there’s the sexy/hot/beautiful/tacky-yet-scantily-glad girl covers that will surely have the guys buying a copy (yes, we are also guilty. Why? Because it sells.).

Not that reiterating these ideas will make them any newer. Back in the (college) day, I wondered why such bland ideas persisted. Then I started working and the ‘ikot ng pera‘ concept of the economy became a reality I lived with. People need to make money, businesses need to grow, and when you earn, you want stuff. It’s empowering to have stuff. But to keep having the stuff to buy, you have to make sure that business grows. People want stuff, and that’s what is sold in magazines, billboard ads, and TV commercials (among other, ahem, body parts). There is nothing wrong with wanting stuff or the need to innovate basic necessities. To keep selling all this stuff, you have to present it with a story that’s familiar. A familiar story/genre/artista is what keeps people’s attention.

But familiarity breeds mediocrity, as Direk Joey observed in his Rogue self-interview. If people aren’t given something new to read about, when will we get our new beginning? Malcolm Gladwell’s article, The Ketchup Conondrum, takes note of Howard Moskowitz’s analysis: “But Moskowitz does not believe that consumers–even spaghetti lovers–know what they desire if what they desire does not exist. ‘The mind,’ as Moskowitz is fond of saying, ‘knows not what the tongue wants.'” The same could be applied to an audience that seeks familiarity–they want what they want now because they know it. And just like a new Facebook layout, give them something new, they will feel uncomfortable but eventually adapt because they use that medium in their lifestyle.

I remember my boss and I disagreeing over a magazine cover. He’s a businessman, so his priority is to sell what we produce. He complains that I think too much like an artist. I preferred cover X since it was local, and it was a pretty good photo. He preferred cover Y (which won, and can be now seen on stands, haha) because the subject was clear. I got his point that with cover X, “it’s risky, it’s either you love it or hate it.” But what if we did push through with cover X? It would definitely get people’s attention–and if you don’t like it, wouldn’t it at least pique your curiosity?

That’s the thing with new beginnings–they grab attention. They don’t need fancy graphics or strobe light presentations to mask a familiar, used up idea. New beginnings are game changers. They could be a success, like what Steve Jobs did with the tablet (iPad), smart phone (iPhone), and mp3 player (iPod), or a failure, as my boss predicted with cover X. But either way, it can grab a short attention span because it’s fresh or reborn. After all, does the consumer really know what he/she wants, until it’s actually there?

2 thoughts on “A borrowed idea fighting for the new

  1. Hi. You have a lot of great points here, particularly on new ideas.

    It brings to mind a lot of the things we now do…and are able to do, thanks to technology. Frankly, I find that just because we now can, we do – even when not all those things are worth our time.

    Likewise, so many ‘new’ things and ‘new’ stories are, as you say, just refurbished versions of old ideas. It’s easier to produce those kinds of things…isn’t it ironic how, with all that we have to be better versions of ourselves (or produce better, new things), we subconsciously insist on remaining the same ‘ol, same mediocrity?

    Okay, pardon my brain farts haha. Humdeedum. If Ernest Hemingway had a difficult time, then my own sweat and blood isn’t even an iota of the hard work he put into his work.

    Oh and, like the ad goes: you can antagonize or praise crazy ideas, but one thing you can’t do is ignore them. Sayang si cover X, but alas, it is the one with money that has the power to change things – or keep them as mediocre as they are.

    • Exactly Johna! Have you read Direk Joey’s self-interview on Rogue? I had so much aha moments, and was thinking of leaving it on the boss’ desk, since even if he was referring to TV, it could be applied to print and the Internet (I also forgot about blogs, haha!). Recycled ideas are a lot like milk tea and frozen yoghurt–everyone will go crazy at the first company, then settle for the several others that follow suit. People are just waiting for a new idea to enter their lives.

      But GAH, tomoooh ka about Ernest Hemmingway. This blog entry palang, not anything new. And partner that with the fact my job actually does the whole recycling thing (remember the boss’ words, why rock the boat when you can do what already works? :)) to make money. Not that I’m denying the need to pay my bills and get by…it’s just that we’re constantly reminded to do great things, and the risk should be worth the trouble if it means educating an audience. Haaaay. Creative woes! :))

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s